Video: The Status of (Modern) Fundraising in the United States | Duration: 3640s | Summary: The Status of (Modern) Fundraising in the United States | Chapters: Fundraising in 2025 (2.56s), Fundraisers' Top Concerns (192.52s), Fundraising Confidence Boosters (331.735s), Resilience and Innovation (700.82s), Continuous Donor Acquisition (1604.42s), Growing Donor Engagement (1677.2649s), Data-Driven Decision Making (1890s), AI in Fundraising (2315.415s), AI in Nonprofits (2683.935s), Implementing AI Responsibly (2919.7598s), Donor-Centric Communication Strategies (3333.1802s), Recurring Engagement Benefits (3507.555s), AI in Grant-Making (3540.795s), Conclusion and Thanks (3600.073s)
Transcript for "The Status of (Modern) Fundraising in the United States": Hi, everybody. Welcome to the state of fundraising in 2025. Today, we'll be examining some key trends and insights to help nonprofit fundraisers. So if you are a nonprofit fundraiser and you're saying help, you're in the right place. For some quick introductions, my name is Kate Everett Anderson. I'm the research and publications lead at the Blackbaud Institute, and I'm joined by our director, Lori Poore. The Blackbaud Institute, if it's new to you, is our research lab that explores topics that are essential to business operations of nonprofits, foundations, CSR teams, and educational institutions. We are also very excited to be joined by Steve McLaughlin, who is VP of client success at SJ Consulting. Great. Thanks, Kate. And, yeah, SJ Consulting, founded by Julie Gibson, nearly twenty years ago, Works with a wide range of nonprofit organizations for both CRM, strategic consulting, digital marketing, and online fundraising practice. I'm really excited to be, here on today's webinar. Thanks for being here. And to give a little bit of grounding, in today's, conversation, we're gonna be talking about a lot of different data from a lot of different places. Just bringing it all together and kinda get a snapshot of what's happening in the sector right now. But our main grounding point will be this report, the status of fundraising in the AI era. This came out very recently from the Blackbaud Institute. You can find a link to it in the doc section, on your module, and we definitely invite you to dive into it. We're just gonna be sharing just a sneak peek of what's inside. But within this, we surveyed 550 US nonprofit education professionals, to get a look at snapshot of growth in the sector, the key drivers of success, and understand the relationship between revenue performance, digital maturity, and AI usage. You know, as we're continuing to adopt AI within the sector, we wanna see how that's influencing the workflows, of those of us who work within the sector. And if you happen to take part in this survey, please let us know in the chat. I know that a lot of our customers, and our friends took part in this, and I'd love to give you a little props for that. And I also wanna mention before we dive in, we'll be talking specifically about US findings, but if you are joining us on demand from The UK or Australia, New Zealand, or if you're here in person from Canada or watching on demand from either, we do have specific reports for your regions as well. So as we go through today, just to give us, a little bit of an outline, we're gonna talk a little bit about, like, where are we now? So what concerns and trends are defining the sector in 2025? And then Steve will go more into, like, what does this mean for your organization? And we'll be talking a little bit more about recommendations and what's next. So we're not just talking about the things that y'all already know about what's happening, but really what you can do with that information now. We'll also have time for a q and a, but we do wanna invite you to go ahead and post your questions within the chat, within the q and a section. And as we go along, we'll also try to address them as well. So I will turn things over to Laurie to set the stage on where we are now with those key concerns and trends that are defining the sector right now. Awesome. Thanks, Kate. So we will jump in here with a look at what is keeping fundraisers up at night. In terms of work related concerns, we asked fundraisers what worried them most in a recent study. You can see in light gray up at the top of the screen here. This is really recently fielded research, coming from April 23 to 05/05/2025, and we were curious to see if there were big differences in the types of concerns that fundraisers had depending on the size of their organization or the specific subsector that they were fundraising in. But, actually, what we observed is that across our sector, we have a lot of the same concerns. So 60% reported that their biggest concern was the economy, just kind of broadly, concerned about revenue and securing adequate funds because of economic forces, outside the direct control of your organization, and 74% of respondents actually clarified that that that concern was, related to the potential impact of a recession. The next area that we saw, in terms of concern was changes in federal policy. So 59% of respondents indicated that they had been impacted by changes in federal funding in 2025. Organizations who'd experienced these changes were more likely to indicate that they had taken, steps like budget cuts or layoffs or pausing programs in responses, to changes in federal funding. And then finally, the other big concern, that was lifted listed was shifting donor demographics. So 58% of fundraisers reported, excuse me, that they were concerned about the decline, in charitable participation and half are concerned about the impact of reduction in major donor participation. Now one of the things that's really interesting to consider when we take a look at these, concerns, the things that the majority of fundraisers are saying concern them is that actually, we also asked in the same study if fundraisers had achieved their fundraising goals, and the vast majority of respondents had either exceeded their goals or achieved their goals. So these are the worries of fundraisers who in in large part are experiencing success and accomplishing the goals they're setting out to accomplish. So, oh, I can't click forward. Can whoever is clicking click forward. Thank you. So before we go on, just curious to hear from you all in the chat of the concerns I just shared. Which is concerning you the most? Are you in that first group, the economy? Are you, feeling the impact of changes in federal funding? Are you thinking about declining donor participation, or is there a different concern, something else? And if you're a different concern, something else, you're a d, go ahead and share that in the chat too. We'll just kinda take a look to get a sense of how this group is feeling. Great. Now, I hope that this is not an example of toxic positivity, but, as we look at this data and we started saying, well, gosh, people have a lot of worries. We're also observing that there's a lot of things that are helping fundraisers feel more confident. I think first on an individual level, like I mentioned, we saw that the vast majority of respondents in that study that we just looked at together, said that they had, achieved or met their, exceeded or achieved their fundraising goals. In terms of other things that we're seeing, drive some confidence for fundraisers is the fact that total giving is up. Total giving grew 3.3% when adjusted for inflation this past year according to Giving USA. We're seeing strong generational participation, so boomers and millennials are leading the way in annual giving, but Gen z isn't far behind considering their life stage. According to some recent Blackbaud Institute, research, we see that 84% of Gen zers support causes in some ways. Large, proportions of that group want to increase their support, and they're doing it in new ways. And there's also new tools at our disposal, as fundraisers. So research is showing a correlation between digital maturity, a culture of innovation, and the achievement of revenue goals. So, we can go to the next slide. I wanna take another little poll here. If there's something putting wind in your sales this morning about, or this afternoon or evening depending where you're you're joining from. I'm curious to learn which of these is making you feel most confident, when it comes to achieving your goals. Oh, and we've got some questions about Gen x, Gen x giving participation. Kate, will we hit that in a second here? We'll You will. Make sure we can links for you. Okay. Yeah. I'll let you go ahead and take over. Kate is research lead and knows, so many things about all the research that is out there for us to take a further look at. Let's see. So my Internet seems to be unstable, so apologies if I go in and out, but I'm just gonna keep on tracking through some data here. So for those of you who are like me who hear all of these wonderful things, like, giving is up. We're seeing this awesome generational participation. You know, I think that a lot of that it does put a lot of wind in my sails. I think that, you know, as Laurie mentioned, despite all the challenges, I know fundraisers are incredibly resilient. The sector is incredibly resilient, but I'd love to see the numbers that back it up. So I just wanted to go in and kinda double click on these and share with you the data that supports all of these findings for this growth in the sector. So, as we mentioned, giving is up. So the Blackbaud, we did an early assessment of 2024 giving, and saw that giving was on its way up. And then we were really excited to see that that was affirmed, through the Giving USA report that just came out in the last week or two. So as Laurie mentioned, it's up 3% when adjusted for inflation. And Giving USA also found that giving by individuals increased 5.1% when adjusted for inflation. This is also supported, by what we saw when looking at the mean individual gift. So when we look at the mean individual gift, across all subsectors, it hit an all time high in 2024. So, of course, when we're looking at donor participation, of course, we want more donors, but those servers who are participating are really throwing in real I'm gonna say throwing in hard. They're throwing in hard. They're giving they're putting their money where their mouth is, and they're giving at this really high level. And one thing that I always like to see is that thank you, Laurie. One thing that I always like to see is how this is experienced on a day to day basis by fundraisers. I was a fundraiser myself, and then looking at numbers, can be encouraging, but it's nice to see your your own reflection. And it was nice to see the third of the professionals, that we surveyed, this past spring saw an increase, year over year. And so we're able to see that reflected within their day to day experience as well. So let's talk about generations. So Gen X specifically, I wanna call out, this chart that is from the recent Giving USA generational, giving report. And we saw across all generations an increase in participation. So, of course, we we love to talk about Gen z here, just because they are I think, you know, we wanna look ahead. We want to start cultivating these supporters while they're young, bring them into the fold, but, of course, that's not at the expense of the millennials, the Gen Xers, even our boomers, looking at their participation continuing to increase over time. So this chart here, you're able to see that across the board, their participation is increasing. We find this particularly interesting, because when we surveyed Gen z donors specifically in 2023, we asked them about their intended gifts over time moving forward, and a third of them plan to increase their giving in 2024. Okay. A good year. We also wanted to call out here, if you have the ability to partner with a with a corporation or the workplace giving or volunteering program, that is a great way in with Gen z and to increase our participation early. Among those that we surveyed for our Gen z at the table report, those respondents whose employers offered workplace giving or volunteer programs, 89% of Gen zers participate within that workplace giving and 92% participate in that volunteerism. And as we know, volunteerism is a great way to get served with an organization, before you're willing to give that first gift. So I really wanted to double click on that for you all as a pathway forward. And so overall, we're seeing these clear indicators of resilience, and we found a few things that were really interesting. I think we often think about, you know, organizational size, your budget, all of these things being kind of indicative of your ability to be resilient. As Laurie mentioned, we did a recent survey, this spring, and we'll be releasing some of that data in a new report, later this summer. And we found some really exciting information that organizations across all different budget sizes, all different employee sizes, have the ability to have proactive measures to mitigate the risks that they're facing. They are more confident than they are concerned about the issues that we were just discussing. And a lot of that comes down to adopting a culture of innovation and their ability to navigate risk. We'll go a little bit more into what that could look like, later in this session. But that's something I really want to call out. You know, also as someone who worked at a organization with a staff of three, I think it's really encouraging to see that this really can expand to all different sizes and, budgets of organizations. We also found we'll touch more on this later, talking about digitally mature organizations. So those who felt that their tech was well integrated, that they were getting the most out of their technology, they were, twice as many of them were able were seen as getting the most other tech investment as those who classify as digitally limited. We'll go more into that later. And those who did identify as digitally limited, so their technology wasn't really keeping up with the integrations that they needed, were less likely than those, than those who were more integrated to experience revenue growth. And so we're seeing kind of these clear indicators of what really powers that resilience and taking advantage of the positive trends that we just saw. So what does that look like on an individual level, and what can you do at your organization in order to foster this kind of resilience in today's environment? I will pass things over to Steve who is gonna give you wonderful wisdom in how to do that. Thanks, Kate and Laurie. I will I'll do my best. Okay. So we've talked about, some of the trends and some of the good news, but I'm sure many of you at the outset who responded about some of your particular concerns are wondering, okay. You're telling me there's some positive trends. There's some good signs in the data. There is indeed some good news, but I'm still feeling some anxiety here. And I still got some concerns about what does it mean for my organization and the nonprofit sector as a whole. So that's what I'm gonna try and focus on here in this section of today's presentation. What does this all mean for your organization? So I wanna talk about a couple of different insights that I gleaned from the data and the trends as we look at things. So insight number one, news flash, challenging times are not a new thing. We may feel like, things going on in the world, in The US, wherever it happens to be, are new and unprecedented and never seen before. But, the history, Buff and Me, tends to push back on that. So if you look at, the history the recent brief history of challenging times going back to nineteen o one, we have always went through a cycle of challenging times of financial crises, panics, wars, recessions, stock market crashes, stock market booms. We could equally create a chart here that shows a brief history of recent non challenging times as well. But the point being, history tends to repeat itself. We are in a cycle right now where you may have both a combination of economic and social, challenges taking place right now. But the key point is this will repeat and nonprofit organizations, and in particular, the fundraising work they do continue to weather these cycles time and time again. So a bit of sort of calming of the nerves of this is not our first challenging times. Maybe for some of us, it's the first challenging times we've lived through in our nonprofit careers, but rest assured, it's not the first period like this across organizations, and there's a lot of data and trends to support these kinds of cycles. Now one way of thinking about this is in calm times, you may not feel like you're living in a snow globe, but maybe right now you do feel like you're living in the fundraiser snow globe. And someone has lifted this thing off the desk and shaped it like a Polaroid picture, for those of you who get that reference, and things seem challenging. It is really cloudy and hard to see. And what we wanna talk about are what are the things to focus on right now given you may be feeling like you're in a very busy snow globe at the moment. So let's talk about a couple of things, and we saw some of these questions come in the chat. So either we're really good at putting content together or you're psychic and you read ahead and saw what our slides are. So for starters, let's pick up where some of where Laurie and Kate left off. So giving in The US, where does this come from? Well, this is the latest data for 2024 from Giving USA. 66% of giving coming from individuals, 19% from foundations, 8% from requests, and 7% from corporations. Keep in mind, the 7% from corporations also includes gift in kind. Fun fact, for those of us who've read way too much into the appendices of giving USA to understand this data. Now this is a snapshot in time. What I find is helpful is not to just look at what is it today, but where has this been trending. And so if you look at the historical data from getting USA, so we're gonna go on a time machine, and we're gonna go back a little over twenty years to 02/2003, you'll see that there have definitely been some shifts going on. So back in 02/2003, don't remember what the number one movie or hit song was, but back then, 74% of giving came from individuals, 11% from foundations, 9% from requests, 6% from corporations. So the quest and corporations have relatively remained the same. But, certainly, you can see there's this big shift in giving from individuals to giving from foundations. But is it really a shift? No. It's not. So the thing you don't see in the data here is that over the past twenty years, there's been a massive increase in the gifts that come from donor advised funds over also known as DAFs. And talk to clients every single day who have DAF gifts that come in, that's where it's coming from. So these gifts there hasn't been an uptick necessarily from foundations giving. There has been an uptick in giving through donor advised funds by individuals. And so a lot of organizations have started to adjust and fine tune their strategy to make sure how are they handling and supporting gifts that come from donor advised funds. Supporting donors and educating donors about donor advised funds are yet another way to give. And so you do see the shift in the data and you might say, wow. You know, foundations giving from them has increased by 8%. It's largely coming from donor advised funds, which is all to say, if you take individuals, 66%, bequest, which are gifts from individuals as well, and some percentage of foundations where you'll end up is the vast majority of giving comes from individuals. That doesn't mean that giving from corporations or or other types of foundations aren't important. But if I, in challenging times, need to focus, then the the area of focus absolutely needs to be on individual giving because that, that is the vast majority of giving, and that trend has held up for quite a while. Now the other side of the coin here is, okay, but where are all of these people and foundations and corporations giving to? Well, here's the latest data from 2024. About 23% goes to religious organizations, 14% to human services, 14% to education, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. Again, you look at this and this looks like a busy donut chart and may be a challenge to sort of make sense of it. So, again, let's get into our data time machine and actually go back forty years. So we're gonna compare 1984, great Van Halen album from 1884. '8 1984 had a lot of great music, from what I recall. So you'll see some dramatic shifts here. So in 1984, giving to religious based organizations with 62%. In 2024, that's 23%. And so you have seen a shift in giving. Right? An increase in giving to educational institutions, health care institutions, foundations, human services, etcetera, etcetera. Now I wanna point this out. This doesn't mean that this is a zero sum game, meaning because someone did not give to a religious based organization and they gave to another kind of organization that someone won and someone lost. The trend is giving has continued to grow, almost every year, but not quite every almost every year for four for for this forty year period of time. You but you've certainly seen a shift. So, faith based organizations continue to raise a tremendous amount of money every year, but you have seen a shift in giving patterns. And we could probably do a whole webinar around what some of those patterns are and because it's related to generational groups and emphasis in giving. But things are changing, but these are still the largest groups where, giving is going to. And we've got sort of that historical evidence that while giving has been shifting, it yes. Absolutely. Has continued to grow over time. Okay. Insight number two. We can spend a lot of time talking about what's changing and what's challenging. I tend to be the contrarian and go the opposite direction, which is let's talk about what's not changing, what's not challenging, or what is unlikely to change. And that starts with again, I'll emphasize the fact that the vast majority of giving comes from individuals and therefore, the common denominator we have to talk about are humans because humans are donors and humans behave in predictable ways. Humans, for the most part, want to do good. Humans give to organizations because they care. We know that humans respond to urgency. Humans love powerful stories. Right? Stories go back a long, long, long time before TikTok, believe it or not. And humans give more in a relationship. And this stuff has been true for a long time before we had CRM technology or the cloud or anything. These are hardwired into human behavior. And so when we are in challenging times, there might be a tendency to think, oh, we like, the the rules don't apply anymore. Things are different. We need to but go back to what is not changing. What is not changing is human behavior and how important giving is to humans and how they react, to, a sense of urgency, powerful stories, being in a relationship with an organization where, they're stewarded, they're communicated with, they're engaged on an ongoing basis. So what am I supposed to do with all that, Steve? Well, just like we would say, there are a bunch of things that haven't changed when it comes to donors despite the technology maybe changing or the environment changing. These are four things I truly believe are true of just about every nonprofit org who's on this call and everyone who isn't as well, which is, at the end of the day, when it comes to running a fundraising program, there are four things you gotta do. Get revenue, keep revenue, grow revenue, reduce cost. I've yet to find a fifth thing or something that someone comes up with, maybe throw it in the chat, that I can't classify in the category of get revenue, keep revenue, grow revenue, and reduce costs. And when we are in challenging times or maybe we're we're looking at it having to change up our tactics or strategy a bit, I really encourage you to go back to these four areas and think about, okay, this thing we wanna do, does it check the box or does that does doing that get revenue, keep revenue, grow revenue, reduce cost? And if it doesn't, you may wanna decide to you're not saying no, you're just saying not now. You might have to put that on the shelf for now. So I wanna step through this in a little bit more detail, beyond just sort of a high level concept. So for starters, when I say get revenue, keep revenue, grow revenue, reduce cost, from a fundraising program perspective, what I'm talking about is get revenue means I need to acquire donor revenue. Notice I'm not saying acquire donors because you could acquire donors and not necessarily acquire revenue. Believe it or not, that does happen. Keep revenue. I need to retain donor revenue. I am not saying, retain donors because that's different than retaining donor revenue. Grow revenue, increase donor revenue, reduce costs. I'm not saying cut stuff out. I my interpretation of reduced cost is improve net revenue. Right? Now some of you in the chat and other places are sort of claiming and say, well, why isn't fulfill your mission on the list? I'm a be really blunt, folks. If you don't do these four things, there is no mission. Right? There's the old phrase of, like, no money, no mission. The fundraising program is an instrumental part of driving your ability to fulfill your mission. And so focusing on these four things are super important. If someone just dropped in the chat, you can't do the mission if you don't have these four things, unless Mackenzie Scott just dropped $20,000,000 check on you when you can't tell anybody about it. In which case, we would know anything either way. Alright. So get revenue. What do I need to do? You need to keep planting seeds even though you might feel like, really? Should I still be focused on acquisition right now? Yes. You should. You shouldn't stop planting seeds. You need to keep acquiring new donors even in challenging times. And we have proof in the data when we go back and look at things like the financial crisis of two thousand eight. There are very well known organizations who stopped acquiring donors, and now they've got a big giant gap in their fundraising program because they stopped. Right? Do not become invisible. Continue to communicate. Continue to engage. Do not chase unicorns. For one, unicorns are not real. But even if you wanna pretend they are, don't chase them. Narwhals either. So, you know, I guess the unicorn is the land equivalent in narwhals in the ocean. You need to focus on new donors, lapsed donors, and long lapsed donors. And what I mean by long lapsed donors is what we know for the research is donors who are lapsed past sixty months are essentially you should treat them like they're a brand new donor in the organization. So if they're super long lapsed, there's an opportunity to reacquire those donors, but you need to think of them as being brand new. Okay. Keep revenue. Love this one. Right? You planted those seeds, you need to keep watering the plants. Don't water the plants, plants won't die. Right? Keep retaining your existing donors. And more importantly, think about, are we really focused on every part of the donor experience? Right? How we communicate the channels we use, the way we measure that. Are we being, very conscious of the fact that we're trying to add value and engagement at every step along the donor experience as opposed to, well, they got the confirmation email on the online gift five seconds after it happened. I think we're good. No. You need to continue to to work on that part of the donor experience. Keep inviting existing donors to stay engaged. We know some works have maybe pulled back from from events or they went from five events to three events, but that doesn't mean you should keep inviting existing donors to stay engaged, whether that's staying engaged in in person events via social media, poll surveys, questionnaires, meet and greets, all those kinds of things. And the other point I think is important here, reaffirm your mission now more than ever. Oftentimes, there's a tendency where there's a maybe it's pressure from leadership of the board of, hey. Maybe we should pull back on talking about what we're doing. Again, that's don't be invisible. And so you absolutely don't wanna do that. In fact, in a lot of cases, reaffirming your mission is more important than it ever has been before. Grow revenue. We planted the seeds. We're watering the plants. Now we have to keep growing those trees. Right? We need to continue to grow revenue from existing donors, whether that's through a focused effort of increasing giving from recurring donors or one time donors, things that we may be doing in membership programs or event related programs. Part of this certainly is is simple and straightforward is, have we taken a good look at the ask amounts that we're using today both online and offline? And certainly, Blackbaud has the magic of technology where there's some ways to automate this within the solutions as well. Are you taking advantage of it? Growth sometimes require some testing, some experimentation. So experiment and test. But if we're in challenging times or maybe a little bit challenging times, don't start over and throw everything out the window. Continue to experiment and test, but do it, within a level that you're comfortable with. And then here's my brief moment of tongue in cheekiness, but I mean it, having done a board before, get the board off their assets. Right? So how we engaging with the board? Is that a renewed matching gift program? Is that a renewed focus on give get? But whatever it is, again, looking for areas that maybe you haven't done before on the growth side and certainly engaging with the board is another great way in order to do that. And then reducing costs. And now for me, reducing costs isn't just cut, cut, cut. This is about how do I increase net revenue, which is, increasing, you know, decreasing cost where it makes sense, but how do I lift, the results that I'm getting to improve net revenue? Yes. You may have to prune branches and dead limbs. If you've been doing a program for a certain period of time and it's really just not driving the results right now, yeah, maybe you need to take a hard look at that. But pruning branches or taking off dead limbs is not the same thing as chopping down the tree, which is what we would recommend you not do. Right? Preserve what measurably drives revenue. Right? If this is something that gets revenue, keeps revenue, or grows revenue, there have to be bright spots in there that things are performing better than others. Let's focus and preserve those things. Leverage data to make informed decisions. And what I mean by that is someone who wrote a book about data driven nonprofits a long time ago is, like, data is your friend. Like, let's look at the data and help us decide. For example, we see orgs right now thinking we used to do five events during this period of time, maybe we'll do three. Okay. Great. If that's the decision, let's look at the data to help us decide which three have performed or have the biggest opportunity for growth in the future. Set goals measure progress. Sounds simple and straightforward yet we see lots of orgs who don't do this. They might set a goal, but then they're not measuring the actual progress. So, again, if you're looking in areas where you might be able to increase net revenue, ways you might be able to prune or or other areas, set goals and measure progress. And certainly last but not least here, don't get distracted by shiny objects. These things come along. You know, I know just as long as what, two years ago, it was giving by crypto, giving by crypto, giving by this, giving by that. Sometimes those shiny objects turn out, sometimes they don't. But in in times like this, don't get distracted by the typical shiny objects. Okay. Insight number three. Sort of tease this one. We bet but here we go. We must make data informed decisions. Otherwise, it's just somebody's opinion. And we all know how that goes. What you really need is some data that you turn into information, and you turn that information in insights to help inform your decisions. It doesn't mean that you turn your decision making over the robots, although we'll get to that one later. But it is super important that you're at least using data to help drive decision making within the organization over personal preference or other kinds of things. So I wanna talk you through an example of how you can turn data into information and insights. So this is my, Oprah moment of the presentation. So everybody on the call today, congratulations. You are all getting getting a 100 brand new donors to your organization. So I'm immediately helping you with that get revenue objective. So you get a 100 donors, you get a 100 donors, you get a 100 donors, you get a 100 of us. Awesome. You're welcome. Now based on the data, we're gonna meet a year from now and see what exactly did you do with those 100 donors. Now thanks to our friends with, Blackbaud's benchmarking capabilities. We know exactly what this is gonna look like in a year from now. So of those 100 donors, if they those donors were acquired offline, so we're talking things direct mail, direct marketing, those types of channels. A year later, you will only have 29 of the 100 donors left. Not great, folks. Not not spectacular. But wait, there's more. If you acquire those donors on the Internet, it's actually works. So first year, online acquired donor retention rate is 22%. So either online, offline, this is not this is not good, and retention is not good here. So part of the point is for for a long time now, organizations battle on this online versus offline thing. It's like jets and sharks or something. And as it turns out, online or offline, like, they the performance here is equally bad. But that challenge is to look at the data and not just look at the data, but look for where's maybe some insights here. So this is the magic trick. We're gonna start over. Let's forget about what just happened, please. It's really freaking about what just happened. Alright. We're gonna start with every one of you gets another 100 brand new donors. So all of you get a 100 brand new ones. We're all set. Except this time, we wanna look at this from a slightly different perspective. So a year from now, if those donors gave a single gift, you're only gonna have 22 of the 100 laps because that is the, first year single gift donor retention rate. Not great. In fact, it sort of does worse than offline and about the same as the Internet. So you're wondering what's happening here. I thought there was a magic trick, Steve. Well, here it is. If you ask those donors to give a recurring gift, you have a very different result here. So and that's because the first year multiple gift donor retention rate is 73%. So, again, would you rather have 73% retention or 22% retention? And I don't think that's a trick question. And yet, we know lots of organizations continue to sort of resist this shift to recurring giving. But the data every year because every year, I update these stats and it stays about the same, is similar. Right? Single gift donors, 22 to 24%. Recurring gift donors, 71 to 73% over the past couple of years. So recurring gift donors retain a lot better. Not to mention that, when we look at revenue per donor, which is a key metric that we like to look at from benchmarking purposes, single gift donors tend to have a revenue per donor of a $108 per year, and recurring gift donors have a revenue per donor of $222 per year. Now you might be saying, but this is cheating, Steve, because recurring gift donors are giving every month, are giving every quarter, and so they're giving more, and so this isn't fair. And it's like, that's the point. They're giving more. And as it turns out, this has zero nada to do with online versus offline. It really is about the frequency of giving and how we're driving donors to give. And so, again, this is one of these things where if you're not really looking for the insight in the data, you might just continue to plow along and say, well, we got bad returns and rates. There's nothing we can do. Turns out, if you look at deeply enough at the data, there is something you can do to focus and improve in this area. So, Kate, you wanna drive from here and and talk about some other related trends? Yeah. I love that as you know, I think that there's a lot of empowerment to data and to looking at these examples. Like, this referring gift example is just one out of so many options that would be able to you if you are able to kinda lead with data. But I know that you're gathering that data, having data health, all of that is kind of part of the same ecosystem. So I wanna take a little bit of a step back, and talk about this from maybe, like, more holistic standpoint, and then we'll get down to a little bit more of the next trends here. So when you're looking at reaching these goals, I wanted to touch a little bit on digital maturity. So what we're looking at here is, the status of fundraising in AI era, the study that we keep referring to. We asked all of the participants to self identify themselves on a spectrum, of digital maturity, so they could rank themselves, from one to 10. So a digitally mature organization, for this study was defined as one where technologies are integrated across all different areas, including fundraising, service delivery, supporter, or student experience, and internal processes. So the average digital maturity was about 5.5. And so when we say digitally immature or digitally limited, what we're looking at are those who fall below that average, of course, the average, and then those who are more digitally mature. And so within this chart, we can see the strong correlation between those whose, revenue increased, but who are digitally average or digitally mature versus those who are more digitally limited. The reason I wanted to bring this up as well is that there was a strong correlation between those who were digitally mature and those who had good data health. So it's all kind of part of the same story, and data is also really important, as we dive into the use of tools like AI. It's really only as good as the data that you feed it. And so as a digitally mature organization, if you wanna get that leg up, being able to be led by reliable data is a really good part of that story. So, again, we're seeing that digitally mature organizations are able to get the most of their resources. And so for those who were seeing an income growth in 2024, a lot of that was being driven by supporters who gave more. So, again, we saw this record high of $937 for individual giving. Those who are more visually mature are able to have more pathways to access that donor, identify them, move forward, and steward them, just as Steve's mentioning, being able to use these tactics, like recurring giving, to get the most out of every gift. And so I'm actually gonna jump ahead here because I want us to dive into kind of the the hot topic of the day, of the year, of the decade, which is AI. So we talk about these digitally mature organizations. That's kind of all across the spectrum. But I think that all of us are very aware that part of that digital landscape, part of this kind of tech innovation is lies within AI adoption. And so, within the same study, we started asking more, about how fundraisers are using AI in their day to day work. We saw, of course, I think, unsurprisingly, 72% are using generative AI. 82% of the participants of the study used AI within their work, on a regular basis. But we're also seeing things like virtual assistance. We're seeing things like prospecting and wealth screening, testing appeals, chatbots, all of these things, these functionalities that can go towards that kind of do general stewardship. And here we can see a breakdown of how this has increased over time. So the red bar you're looking at is less than a year ago. So people who are using AI less than they were a year ago, and the green is those who are using these different, tools more than they were a year prior. And I think, you know, of course, we see a lot across, you know, drafting content, developing, newsletters, emails, all these kind of generative AI functions, but I also really wanted to call out this greater instance of using it for wealth prospecting, of using it for appeals, using chatbots. You know, all of this is kind of showing this deeper level of use of AI within the workflows of fundraising, and that's really exciting to me. And one thing that we don't have time to get into, really in-depth here but that I would love to draw your attention to for the report is that we asked, we asked about digital maturity, and we also asked about AI usage. And from that, we were able to identify four different personas. And each of these are based on, they each are based on their level of digital maturity and whether or not they use AI. And so as you go through the report, you can kind of identify where you sit right now. There are those who are a little bit more tentative, those who are hesitant to even get started with AI usage, those who are a little bit more open minded, who are starting to experiment, and those who are who see themselves as early adopters. And we saw across the board, really interesting instances of how they're utilizing technology, their digital maturity, and their revenue growth over time. So I just invite you to examine that a little bit more closely within the report itself. But, of course, with all AI usage and anything new, there comes concerns, and there should be weighted concerns to the adoption of any technology, and it needs to be used responsibly. And so we also asked about where those concerns lie. And, of course, inaccurate output and misinformation, data security right behind that were kind of the top concerns, across organizations. But one thing that we found that was really interesting, was that not a lot of organizations had an AI policy in place. So there's room to do more investigation into responsible use of AI. And I think, Steve has a little bit more to share about kind of these perceptions and how you could start adopting AI within your fundraising to kinda have that data led approach. Great. Thanks, Kate. So, AI. When we talk about AI, this for some of us is the first thing that comes to mind. I am a believer that in the movies, the reason we got Skynet and the Terminator is it was a result of bad data. Bad data results in bad robots, which is why we keep talking about still the importance of data help. Now so AI is not new. So, again, history repeating yourself. A lot of the early AI research actually goes back to the nineteen fifties, and we could spend all day talking about that. But this is this isn't new, folks. It's just become more consumer oriented, and in many ways, things that we're now using on a day to day basis. And I can guarantee you with a 100% certainty that everyone on this presentation today, at some point, in the past few years, has used AI whether they knew it or not because AI is is already been exist is already in existence. We're just seeing a lot more of it now than before. And the thing about AI is this stuff takes time. Anyone remember Clippy from 1996? Like, you're you were working in a spreadsheet or write a letter and this paper clip comes up and says, hey, Steve. It looks like you're writing a letter. Like, what is this thing? Please turn this off. Right? Well, Microsoft did turn it off at least for a few years, but it's back. It's called Copilot. But it's that same concept of how do I have a digital assistant that maybe in 1996 was a little weird and a little too early. But now I can't say the Alexa word or the Siri word because my phone or Alexa will go I'll have to be quiet. But, like, we live with these assistance today. So it takes time, but this stuff does mature and does get better. And so part of our role in the nonprofit sector and and and companies like Blackbaud is, you know, how do we leverage this technology, for good? And so certainly, Blackbaud has used, AI, predictive AI for a long time, whether you knew it or not. Little thing called intelligence for good. And you're gonna start to see the emergence of more of these kinds of things, like, the use of generative AI. But I think the real potential on the horizon is what the the kids call AgenTic AI, which is the use of agents. So rather than write me a letter or read this 50 page RFP and give me the highlights, AgenTic AI is all about performing tasks. And if there's anything that's been true of nonprofit organizations of every shape and size, almost all of you wear multiple hats. Some days five hats, some days 12 hats. And so if things like AgenTic AI could be used to wear one of those hats, and it just does this thing now, that would free us up to do a lot more focus in some areas that potentially were not focused on today. The last thing I'll leave you is, yes, there's a ton of hype about AI, but I love this quote by Larry Tesla, which says, AI is whatever hasn't been done yet. Because the moment it has been done, everyone then says, oh, that's not AI. That's machine learning. That's not AI. That's this. So rest assured, when people talk about AI, it's like remember when everyone used to talk about cloud, cloud, cloud, cloud, cloud, cloud, but they couldn't really explain it? Now it's like it's it's there's no cloud. It's somebody else's computer in the cloud. Who cares? Move on. That's kinda where with AI. There's a lot of hype. There's a lot of talk. But rest assured from a technology perspective, a lot of what may be referred to AI is just gonna become native parts of the applications and the tools that we use today. Laurie, save me. Well yeah. So when we talk about a big picture idea like AI, I'm always the person who's sitting there going like, okay. But what what am I supposed to do tomorrow? Like, what am I supposed to do right now with this information that you shared with me? So just wanna leave you with if if you're an organization thinking about how you integrate AI into what you're doing and to do it responsibly, I've got three things I wanna encourage you to think about. First, Steve was talking before, in a different context using the phrase don't get distracted by shiny objects. Same thing is true here. We need to start with knowing our goals. So, you will discover how to use AI most effectively through experimentation, but experimentation without a goal is a hobby pursuit. Right? Like, you need to understand what goals you are trying to accomplish through your experimentation, how you're gonna measure what you're accomplishing, so that you can know, the best way to move with, greater speed towards the goals that you're trying to accomplish. So for us, in our AI experimentation that, you know, we do on my team here, we have a couple of really concrete goals that we're trying to solve. We are trying to get more effective about the way we brief each other on projects. We are trying to decrease the amount of time we spend on certain tasks. We know those things that we're working on, and we're tracking our goals towards them so we know whether or not our experiments have been effective. Second thing, know your tech. You know, I work at Blackbaud, so I'm really familiar with the AI that we're integrating into our products at Blackbaud, and I'm really excited about it. As I have chatted with, especially maybe some of your colleagues who are frontline fundraisers and who are maybe less in the system day to day, there's a lot that we've integrated that they are not yet aware of or not yet harnessing. I've had folks tell me that they are using ChatGPT, for example, to write acknowledgments to donors when they actually could use the acknowledgment drafter that's right within Raiser's Edge NXT to use information already about their donors in their system, produce a draft, review it with the human touch, and send it out. Because technology is advancing so quickly, there is more for all of us to keep up with than ever. I do not ignore an email I get from the, providers of any of the pieces of tech I use in my tech stack because everything I use is getting enriched with new AI tools right now. And the same is true for you, especially if you're a Blackbaud customer. We're, we're integrating a lot. So I encourage you to check out the future of Razer's Edge NXT, recording that you can see in the doc section if you are a Blackbaud customer on that product to learn more. And then really importantly, know your policies. Know what your policies are at your organization for adopting AI, for protecting the data of your donors, for protecting the intellectual property of your organization, and for maintaining trust with your audiences. It's critical that you have a documented AI policy. If you don't have one at your organization, this is a great step for you to take. We don't build trust with our donors through random experimentation. We build trust through clear guide rails and knowing how we're gonna apply new technology. So if you don't have an AI policy, really encourage you to develop one. And, if you do have one, make sure sure that you are consulting it as you are seeing the different tools that your vendors might be adding to the different, pieces of technology in your tech stack. Matt, thanks for asking this question. Does Blackbaud have any AI policy templates? Because we were just wondering if that is something folks would find useful. If that's a tool you'd like the Blackbaud Institute to put out in the chat, just give a, thumbs up to Matt's comment. And if that's something you're looking for, we are happy to, to work on that. And I see Paul Putnam is asking, can't AI draft one for us? It might be a good starting point. But we are the ultimate owners of our relationships with our constituents. So we need to to, ultimately own the policies that we are signing up for. Okay. That's my big three in terms of how we can harness AI potential. I think now we have a little bit of time, just a couple minutes for q and a. We've covered a lot of ground today. If you remember way back fifty four minutes ago, we were talking about what worries keep us up at night, what, positive trends are putting wind in our sails. Steve took us through a brief history of history and, helped us think about, how the more things change, the more they stay the same. And even if the snow is flurrying in our snow globe, there are some things that we can be doing right now. And then Kate brought us through how orgs are using AI. So if you have questions on any of those items, we'd love to hear them. So for my own personal, bias, Tammy, I'd love to start with your question, because I think it opens up a lot of potential here. How does a two person arts nonprofit in a small metro area integrate technology and develop data health? As someone who used to work at a three person non arts nonprofit, I know that it's very much based in kind of, like, incremental growth, and I think, you know, keeping an eye to best practices, of course, not taking on too much. But I wonder, Steve, if I can cold call you for some more detached advice. Do you have Yeah. I was looking at that question too, and immediately, I went to this is where having these types of capabilities, automation of data help, automation of some of these processes or workflows within the tools you're using, actually, in in some ways, may help smaller organizations more than larger organizations. Because if you are a two or a three person arts organization, leaning into let some of the the technology and the tools do more of that lift for you that should free you up to focus on more of the human side of the interaction that we know as fundraisers is so important. So I would say, in that case, the the the pivotal role technology plays here is even more important because it can help you get some scale and some leverage to be able to focus more on other aspects as opposed to trying to do everything manually, with with fingers and keyboards. Mhmm. And I know too with the amount of hats that you're wearing, I would also say to to look at these kinds of examples of data driven growth and share them with your board or, with any kind of decision makers to advocate for develop developing your data health, developing time that you can dedicate to your data. All of that, I think, very much goes into the strategic planning elements that we look at too. See. So, let's see. Another question. We have four minutes. Oh, I would love to a quest yeah. Lori, go ahead. Well, there's a question here that I think is for Steve. It says you talked about the strategies for retaining or bringing back donors. The main one is communication. As a nonprofit school, what do donors connect with the moat, what do donors connect with connect with the most with these touch points? Is it the story of the student, the graduate, or is it where their dollars are going? Well, I know we wanna be more individually focused. Sometimes the mass contact has to happen first. Is it the service story or the donor dollar budget? So, again, Steve, I'd love to also cold call on you for this one. This just feels right up your alley. I I I don't wanna put words in the questioner's mouth, but it sounds a little bit like the question is, is there a best practice, for the messages that resonate most for for driving these kind of, relational opportunities? Yes. Absolutely, Lori. So when it comes to building engaging relationships with existing donors, perhaps even lapsed donors, there may be the tendency to, make it all about you. Right? Here's what's going on at school. Here's what's going on at the organization. Us. Us. Us. Me. Me. Me. Me. Me. And that may be fine if the audience, is non donors and you're trying to provide an update on things, parents, staff, you know, patrons, members, whatever happens to me. But the the simple reality is when it comes to donor engagement, you need to adjust your communication to the donor. It's gotta be the hero of the story. And that's a lesson I learned many, many years ago, but always seems to work in practice. So and it could be as simple as reread through that last email communication we sent out that direct mail piece and and underline the number of times we refer to ourselves as the organization. And just a simple thing of flipping that language to how did the donor help make that progress in the organization? How did the donor drive those, particular results? And it's a really simple but very powerful twist, which is make the hero the donor of all of these stories as opposed to the organization or or other stakeholders. Save that for other kinds of communication, but it runs to donor engagement, whether you're a school or any really other type of nonprofit, really focusing on how what is the critical role that the donor helped play or could play in the future by, either, starting to support, increasing their support, those kinds of things over time. And if I could tag on to that, there was a question about, memberships and if those are included within the recurring donor model. Is that something that you would include within that data? I'll give you I'll give you a a gold star for that one. I mean, as long as it's the key thing is whether it's a membership or or not, it's the fact that it's recurring in nature, and that means that over time, you can increase those amounts. You could potentially, if it's a membership program, change the benefits. But the key point is we we want them to be constantly, consistently engaging with the org over time, and anything that is more recurring, regardless of what you call it, performs better. Yeah. Mhmm. Wonderful. Shauna, I see that you have a question here, about foundations and granting organizations utilizing AI. I have a colleague that can ask about that. We don't have specific Blackbaud Institute data at this moment, but I will get back to you. Yeah. I gotta believe there are grant making foundations in order to have used generative a API to to summarize proposals and summarize documents. Gotta believe that's happening. We just need let's go do some research. Yes. And, Morrie, within your question about foundation applications, general grant applications, everything that goes into this and whether AI is capable of building that. I know that we within our, social impact start up group, we have several, several start ups that we're developing tools specifically for that purpose. And so, Lori, I don't know if you have anything else to add there, but I know that this is absolutely a way that AI can help you, within that process. Well, very well said. Alright. So we are at time. I wanna thank everybody for being so engaged. I wanna thank Steve and Laurie so much for your insights. Everything will be shared with you via email, the recording here, the decks. And if there are any questions that we can answer via email, we will follow-up with you there as well. Thank you so much. And there will be a feedback survey if you'd like to participate at the end. Great. Thanks, Tom. And thanks for all you can put on the on the creation of a policy template. We'll get to working on that too, and, you'll know you were here to to request the creation of it as soon as we're able to get it out to you. Thank you all. Thank you.